Outside the Cone: Unique Homemade Ice Cream in Lynchburg, VA

Nestled in the heart of Lynchburg, VA, Outside the Cone is a standout ice cream shop that redefines what it means to indulge in frozen treats. This local gem beckons both ice cream aficionados and casual dessert seekers with its inventive flavors, welcoming ambiance, and commitment to quality that’s evident in every bite.

At Outside the Cone, the ice cream experience transcends the ordinary. Their menu showcases delightful classics like the Banana Chunk—fresh bananas lightly caramelized to perfection, blended with semi-sweet chocolate chips for an irresistibly creamy and fruity harmony. Fans of nutty flavors will be enchanted by the Butter Pecan, boasting buttery, hand-toasted pecan pieces folded into a rich, buttery ice cream base. And no visit is complete without sampling the Cookie Dough, a classic vanilla ice cream studded with housemade chocolate chunks that offer a nostalgic, chewy contrast. For those seeking extra indulgence, freshly made waffle cones and bowls, available with various toppings, add a satisfying crunch and visual delight to every order.

What truly sets Outside the Cone apart is their dedication to inclusivity and innovation. Offering a range of special dietary options such as keto, sugar-free, dairy-free, and gluten-free variations, they ensure that everyone can enjoy their handcrafted creations. Their gluten-free waffle cones, available on weekends, are a particular favorite—light, crispy, and completely dairy-free, satisfying even the most discerning palates. From vegan selections to creative seasonal offerings featuring fresh, locally sourced fruits, this shop reflects both creativity and care in every scoop.

Stepping into Outside the Cone, visitors are immediately enveloped by an inviting and vibrant atmosphere. As customers like Sam Mtshali have shared, the colorful decor combined with warm, attentive staff make it a joyful place to unwind and savor your treat. The spacious indoor seating and charming sidewalk tables provide perfect settings for everything from casual family outings to relaxed dates. Marisa Ransom’s rave about the unique “flight of ice cream” also highlights the shop’s commitment to elevating the tasting experience, allowing patrons to sample four handcrafted flavors artfully presented on a wooden board—a genius concept that caters to adventurous taste buds.

Patrons repeatedly praise Outside the Cone’s inventive Flavor Lab, an incubator for constantly evolving and entirely fresh concoctions. Caleb Stone sums it up perfectly, calling it “the best ice cream shop in the burg”—a testament to the unbeatable freshness and creativity found here. Whether you’re craving a classic cone, a decadent chocolate-dipped waffle cone, or a taste of the latest experimental flavor, this shop delivers consistently delightful surprises.

In summary, Outside the Cone is much more than your average ice cream parlor. With its thoughtfully crafted flavors, inclusive menu, and welcoming vibe, it offers a heartfelt invitation to savor the sweet pleasures of life in Lynchburg. If you’re a local or just passing through, making a stop here isn’t just a treat—it’s an experience you’ll want to revisit time and again.

Contact: 1305 Enterprise Dr, Lynchburg, VA 24502, United States | Phone: +1 434-219-6096

Delivery
In-store shopping
On-site services
Takeaway
Dine-in
Same-day delivery

Solo dining

Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible entrance

Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Sam Mtshali

10/12/2025

A Sweet Treat at Out of the Cone Ice Cream in Lynchburg! I recently had the pleasure of visiting Out of the Cone Ice Cream in Lynchburg, and I must say, it's a game-changer for ice cream lovers! From the moment I walked in, I was greeted with a warm and inviting atmosphere. The colorful decor and friendly staff immediately put me in a sweet mood. But the real magic happens when you take a bite of their delicious ice cream! I opted for a unique flavor combination, and let me tell you, it was love at first bite! The flavors were rich, creamy, and perfectly balanced. What truly sets Out of the Cone apart is the quality of their ingredients and the care they put into crafting each flavor. You can tell they're passionate about creating unique and delicious treats that bring joy to their customers. What Sets Out of the Cone Apart: - Unique and creative flavor combinations - High-quality ingredients and careful crafting - Friendly and welcoming staff - Colorful and inviting atmosphere Tips for Future Visitors: - Be adventurous and try a unique flavor combination! - Ask the staff for recommendations – they're happy to help! - Don't forget to take a photo with their fun and colorful backdrop! In conclusion, Out of the Cone Ice Cream in Lynchburg is a must-visit destination for anyone with a sweet tooth. With their creative flavors, high-quality ingredients, and welcoming atmosphere, you're sure to leave with a smile on your face and a spring in your step!

Bob T

24/11/2025

- - - Special Dietary Options Available - - - The award winning hand-made ice cream is a delectable treat. They offer keto, sugar free, dairy free and gluten-free options - though all of the traditional ice creams are excellent. The gluten free waffle cone (available on Saturdays & Sundays only) is highly recommended with a great taste and is also dairy free. The Toasted Coconut Chunk has plenty of chunks of chocolate and coconut while not being over-flavored by the coconut. The award winning Off The Block Chocolate has a nice rich Belgian chocolate flavor. The Espresso Chunk is a strong coffee flavored ice cream and the Pistachio (not a regular menu item) is smooth and creamy with slight pistachio pieces and delicate flavor. Pints are available "to-go" and seemed to be a pretty popular request.

Marisa Ransom

10/11/2025

A flight of ice cream? Sign me up! I have never seen this done before and I have to say it’s genius! You get to choose 4 flavors and they present it nicely on a wooden board. They are all house made and super delicious. They even have vegan options, whoa! There is a good amount of indoor seating as well as sidewalk tables. They have a nice selection of merch as well. Very reasonably priced and friendly staff. I would highly recommend this place.

Caleb Stone

21/10/2025

Best ice cream shop in the burg easily. What sets them apart is the flavor lab. They always have wonderful new concoctions worked up that are all created and made fresh in house! My family has been coming here for years and have never been disappointed. If your up for an auger rush go for their chocolate dipped waffle cones they don’t disappoint our son would agree!

Rye Maclone

10/10/2025

Went on a Friday night and they ran out of seats because of how packed they were. The ice cream is good and prices are not unreasonable. You get slightly more than you expect in your bowl if you order one, so that was a welcome surprise, a you are able to mesh multiple flavors in one cup or cone! Overall, a good place to come and enjoy some ice cream with friends or family.

Jen Pardee

24/09/2025

I love finding gems of new places when I travel. I also love homemade ice cream, so I was thrilled to find outside the cone. Here are some of the highlights that made this a great visit . 1. Really yummy ice cream. 2. Homemade waffle cones and waffle bowls, but even had chocolate and rainbow sprinkles on the cones. 3. Extra points for non-dairy alternatives in their homemade ice cream. 4. Bonus points for super clean bathrooms. 5. Five stars and a for a super friendly staff. I definitely recommend outside the con for any day. You just need some random ice cream.

Nicolas Velilla

17/09/2025

Homemade ice cream that genuinely tastes crafted. Original flavors and ideas that other places can’t compete with. I visit ice cream shops around the country, this place is a cut above. I take out of town visitors here and they agree. There’s lots of ice cream in Lynchburg, but this is the highest quality.

Holly Souza

09/09/2025

Great people and great flavors. Seasonal always uses fresh fruit in season. Different flavors, all made right there. Espresso and coconut my favorite. Give them a try. You won't be disappointed!